When Saw We Thee?

Homily for Evensong, 19 November 2026

Matthew 25:31-46

Whenever I come to this part of St Matthew’s Gospel, I am reminded of the silliness of the claim that contrasts a violent Old Testament God with a gentle New Testament Jesus. I can turn to any page of the Old Testament you like and show you a God far more gentle than the Jesus who speaks to us tonight.


In this chapter, our Lord speaks three times of his return. First, in the Parable of the Ten Virgins, of which five were foolish, and their end was the door to the party slammed shut in their face, with the words of the groom ringing in their ears “truly I say to you, I do not know you”. Then he gave us the Parable of the Talents, and the lazy servant who was cast into the outer darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth. Tonight we heard the final of the three in this chapter, in which our Lord speaks of separating sheep from goats; the sheep, to everlasting life, and the goats to eternal punishment.


The Old Testament God was always saving the people, no matter how wicked they were. Jesus is casting people into eternal punishment. Can we put away this silly claim about the two Testaments now!


I will not say much here about the gravity of the implication of our Lord’s parable as regards the next life. This Gospel reading will come up again this Sunday, and I will treat with that there. But enough to say that this is serious business in Jesus’ mind – so let us look to where he is pointing.


We see the Son of Man coming in glory, and separating the people out into two camps. One group helped the needy, and the other did not. This is the conviction to our hearts. Our Lord thinks very highly of the needy (remember the Old Testament God who always saved the people when they cried out for help?). The people who help others are the ones who enter everlasting life.


Look at the reason why they get everlasting life; and look at their confusion. Their reward is because whenever they helped “the least of these” they were helping the Son of Man himself. And their confusion is because they did not realise it at the time.


And this is the nature of charity. To the natural flesh, charity sucks – let’s be honest. True charity, that of completely selfless giving, goes against everything in our nature. And before the hippy calls out that he doesn’t need religion to be a good person, man, let me respond: what if his charity were in complete secret? If no-one saw him do it, and the person receiving the charity didn’t know he did it? One step further – if he didn’t even get that warm, fuzzy feeling you get from helping out someone else? Would he still do charitable works?


Because this is the high challenge laid down for us by our Lord. He said “when you helped others, you helped me”, and his people reply, “but we didn’t see you”. We don’t see Jesus when we perform charitable works – or at least, not in the way you might expect.


Consider the greatest charitable work of all: Christ’s humiliation, and his atoning sacrifice on the cross. The people didn’t want it; he didn’t enjoy it; no-one “saw” salvation “happen”. And yet if he hadn’t, we would not be worshipping him as Lord. We would be without hope.


This is, I think, what it means to perform charitable works. There is no room for the pride of self-satisfaction by helping out someone else. It is a complete self-emptying after the pattern of the Lord Jesus. It sucks, it is painful, it goes against our natural instincts. And yet when we do, we do it to and for the Lord. More than that – we become like him.


Tonight we remember St Elizabeth of Hungary. She was a medieval noblewoman who used all her royal resources to distribute bread and medical help to the poor of her realm, wearing ratty old clothes and spending all her time with monks and lepers. She died young – in her 20’s – and is memorialised as a great saint of charitable works. The high calling our Lord places on us, to be a sheep and not a goat, can be and has been done before. In fact, it is a great gift of God’s grace that he has given us so many ways to be like Jesus, and doing charitable works is just such a one.


So let us be people who are pressing after the goal of being close to and being like Jesus. Let us take up this high calling to be charitable people, as a cross to bear, perhaps, but more so as an answer to God’s gracious offer of a means to get closer to him.

Previous
Previous

A House Of Prayer.

Next
Next

Come Up Here.